So there is this place called 16 handles that I used to pass on my walk to work every morning. I hadn't any idea that this east village shop would soon be a haven for my "guilty days" until I decided to check it out. There are 16 "handles", each a different flavor of non-fat frozen yogurt and it is a DIY operation. My personal favorite are banana, vanilla, green tea & blueberry.
After you fill your cup, there is a toppings bar in which you get to load up your fro-yo with all different kinds of stuff.
When you've loaded up your cup, you simply plop it down on the scale at the register and are charged based on how much your dessert weighs. I think the most I've spent was $6.50 - and that was on a day when I opted to have 16 Handles for dinner. I highly recommend it. - 2nd Ave & 9th Street.
http://www.16handles.com/about.htm